Case Files
Ten real cases on the risks fine artists and galleries actually face. Each article gives the facts, the holding, and what policy may have covered the loser, or where no standard policy would have.
- 01Cohen v. G and M Realty: the 5Pointz whitewashMoral rights, destruction of work of recognized stature under VARA
5Pointz was a Queens warehouse complex whose exterior walls carried aerosol art by dozens of artists, curated by Jonathan Cohen. Developer Gerald Wolkoff, who owned the buildings, allowed the work and at times encouraged...
- 02Serra v. GSA: Tilted Arc is removedRemoval and destruction of site-specific public art, contract and ownership
Richard Serra's Tilted Arc was a 120-foot curved steel wall commissioned by the General Services Administration for $175,000 for Federal Plaza in New York. Workers and neighbours objected, hearings followed, and the GSA ...
- 03Carter v. Helmsley-Spear: work made for hire defeats VARAWork made for hire, VARA scope, commission status
Three sculptors created a walk-through sculptural installation in the lobby of a Queens office building, under a commission agreement. When the building owner planned alterations, the artists sought a VARA injunction. Th...
- 04MASS MoCA v. Buchel: the unfinished installationUnfinished work, display and modification, museum and artist contract
Christoph Buchel was commissioned to build Training Ground for Democracy, a football-field-sized installation at MASS MoCA. The work was never finished, the museum and the artist fell out over costs, access, and control,...
- 05Warhol Foundation v. Goldsmith: Orange PrinceFair use, appropriation, licensing into the source market
Lynn Goldsmith photographed Prince in 1981. Andy Warhol made a silkscreen series from the photograph in 1984. In 2016 the Warhol Foundation licensed Orange Prince to Conde Nast for $10,000, for a magazine cover marking P...
- 06Cariou v. Prince: Canal ZoneAppropriation, fair use, gallery co-liability
Patrick Cariou published Yes Rasta, a book of photographs of Rastafarians in Jamaica. Richard Prince used 28 of the photographs in his Canal Zone paintings, shown at Gagosian Gallery, which was a co-defendant. The trial ...
- 07Rogers v. Koons: String of PuppiesCopyright infringement, parody, gallery co-liability
Art Rogers photographed a couple holding a litter of puppies and sold the image as a postcard. Jeff Koons copied it into String of Puppies, a painted wood sculpture, and sold three copies for $367,000 in total through So...
- 08De Sole v. Knoedler Gallery: the forged Abstract ExpressionistsForgery, misattribution, fraud, breach of warranty
Knoedler Gallery, open for 165 years, sold buyers works attributed to Rothko, de Kooning, and other Abstract Expressionists, sourced through dealer Glafira Rosales. The works were forgeries. Buyers alleged the gallery so...
- 09Kraken v. Jacobs: the Botticelli lost in a gallery bankruptcyConsignment, bankruptcy, unperfected interest, bailee liability
Kraken consigned a Botticelli, Madonna and Child, worth at least $8.5 million, to Salander-O'Reilly Galleries, and filed no UCC-1 financing statement to perfect its interest. When the gallery filed for bankruptcy, the pa...
- 10Close v. Sotheby's: the resale royalty that federal law preemptedResale royalties, federal preemption, California Resale Royalties Act
California's Resale Royalties Act, Cal. Civ. Code 986, gave fine artists 5 percent on resales, with the seller's agent, an auction house, gallery, or dealer, to withhold it. Chuck Close and other artists sued Sotheby's a...