ARTIST LIABILITY

Case File No. 05 · Photography, Image and Rights

Warhol Foundation v. Goldsmith: Orange Prince

Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, 598 U.S. 508 (2023)

Andy Warhol at Moderna Museet, Stockholm, 1968

Lasse Olsson

Andy Warhol, Stockholm, 1968

Photograph by Lasse Olsson, Pressens bild, public domain. Public domain Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The artist, with his Brillo boxes behind him. Orange Prince and Goldsmith's Prince photograph are copyrighted and are not shown.

Court
Supreme Court of the United States, decided May 18, 2023, 7-2
Exposure
Fair use, appropriation, licensing into the source market

What happened

Lynn Goldsmith photographed Prince in 1981. Andy Warhol made a silkscreen series from the photograph in 1984. In 2016 the Warhol Foundation licensed Orange Prince to Conde Nast for $10,000, for a magazine cover marking Prince's death, the same purpose as Goldsmith's original photograph. Goldsmith sued. The Supreme Court held that the first fair use factor did not favour the Foundation, because the licensing use shared substantially the same purpose as the original and was commercial. New expression alone was not dispositive. The Court decided only factor 1, and only the licensing use, not Warhol's 1984 creation.

What the court held

When a secondary use serves the same purpose as the original, in the same market, factor 1 weighs against fair use, even if the secondary work adds new expression. The decision turns on use, not on whether the art is transformative in the abstract.

What may have covered it

The loser was the Foundation, and this is the classic media liability case. A media liability or intellectual property infringement defence policy, of the IPISC type, may have funded the defence and any judgment. Commercial general liability would not have, because modern ISO general liability excludes most copyright claims except a narrow advertising injury slice. The lesson is that licensing an appropriation into the source photographer's own market is the highest risk use.

Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, the facts, and the state. Nothing here is a promise of coverage, and Artist Liability does not sell insurance on this page.

Sources

Supreme Court opinion

Back to all Case Files

Previous: MASS MoCA v. Buchel: the unfinished installationNext: Cariou v. Prince: Canal Zone