ARTIST LIABILITY

Case File No. 09 · Galleries and Exhibitions, Consignment

Kraken v. Jacobs: the Botticelli lost in a gallery bankruptcy

Kraken Investments Ltd. v. Jacobs, In re Salander-O'Reilly Galleries, S.D.N.Y. 2012

Madonna and Child and Two Angels, by Sandro Botticelli

Sandro Botticelli

Madonna and Child and Two Angels, Sandro Botticelli

Sandro Botticelli, public domain, Google Art Project scan. Public domain Source: Wikimedia Commons.

A Botticelli Madonna and Child, not the consigned painting, which was lost in the gallery's bankruptcy.

Court
U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, 2012, affirming the bankruptcy court. Gallery bankruptcy filed Nov. 1, 2007, case 07-30005.
Exposure
Consignment, bankruptcy, unperfected interest, bailee liability

What happened

Kraken consigned a Botticelli, Madonna and Child, worth at least $8.5 million, to Salander-O'Reilly Galleries, and filed no UCC-1 financing statement to perfect its interest. When the gallery filed for bankruptcy, the painting was included in the estate sale. The bankruptcy court and then the district court held the unperfected interest lost to the trustee under Bankruptcy Code section 544. Salander-O'Reilly's failure left nearly $120 million unpaid to artists and heirs, according to reports cited in the ALI institutional research.

What the court held

A consignor who does not perfect its interest can lose the work to a bankruptcy trustee, even though the gallery never owned it. Consignment is a property and paperwork position first, and a trust claim second.

What may have covered it

The loser was the consignor, and this is the consignment trap in one fact. A gallery bailee or dealers block policy may have covered the work if it had been stolen, burned, or broken in the gallery's care, but it does not cover insolvency or commingled proceeds. That risk is not insurable by a standard form. It is a trust account, a segregated account, and a perfected UCC filing, backed by the artist's own wall-to-wall fine art policy as a backstop for physical loss only.

Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, the facts, and the state. Nothing here is a promise of coverage, and Artist Liability does not sell insurance on this page.

Sources

JD Supra, Lessons from History: Protecting Artists

Back to all Case Files

Previous: De Sole v. Knoedler Gallery: the forged Abstract ExpressionistsNext: Close v. Sotheby's: the resale royalty that federal law preempted