ARTIST LIABILITY

Case File No. 10 · Studio Practice, Galleries and Exhibitions

Close v. Sotheby's: the resale royalty that federal law preempted

Close v. Sotheby's, Inc., 894 F.3d 1061 (9th Cir. 2018)

Portrait of Chuck Close

LoKiLeCh

Chuck Close

Photograph by LoKiLeCh, CC BY-SA 4.0. CC BY-SA 4.0 Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The artist.

Court
U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit, 2018
Exposure
Resale royalties, federal preemption, California Resale Royalties Act

What happened

California's Resale Royalties Act, Cal. Civ. Code 986, gave fine artists 5 percent on resales, with the seller's agent, an auction house, gallery, or dealer, to withhold it. Chuck Close and other artists sued Sotheby's and Christie's for royalties on post-1978 sales. The Ninth Circuit held the Act expressly preempted by the 1976 Copyright Act for sales after Jan. 1, 1978, leaving only a window from Jan. 1, 1977 to Jan. 1, 1978.

What the court held

A state resale royalty that conflicts with the federal copyright scheme is preempted for sales after the Copyright Act took effect. Artists in California have no statutory resale royalty for the great majority of secondary market sales.

What may have covered it

The losers were the artists and their estates, and no policy covers this. Lost future royalties are not a fortuitous physical loss, a liability claim, or an intellectual property defence cost. It is a legislative risk, and the cover, if any, would have been a contract term, a resale royalty in the original sale agreement, not insurance.

Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, the facts, and the state. Nothing here is a promise of coverage, and Artist Liability does not sell insurance on this page.

Sources

CDAS summary of Close v. Sotheby's

Back to all Case Files

Previous: Kraken v. Jacobs: the Botticelli lost in a gallery bankruptcy