ARTIST LIABILITY

Case File No. 02 · Sculpture and Installation, Public Art

Serra v. GSA: Tilted Arc is removed

Serra v. U.S. General Services Administration, 847 F.2d 1045 (2d Cir. 1988)

Portrait of Richard Serra, 2005

Oliver Mark

Richard Serra, Siegen, 2005

Photograph by Oliver Mark, CC BY-SA 4.0. CC BY-SA 4.0 Source: Wikimedia Commons.

The artist. No license-free photograph of Tilted Arc itself exists, so the portrait leads the file.

Court
U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit, 1988
Exposure
Removal and destruction of site-specific public art, contract and ownership

What happened

Richard Serra's Tilted Arc was a 120-foot curved steel wall commissioned by the General Services Administration for $175,000 for Federal Plaza in New York. Workers and neighbours objected, hearings followed, and the GSA removed the sculpture in 1989 and stored it. Serra sued, arguing removal violated his First Amendment speech rights and his Fifth Amendment rights. The Second Circuit affirmed dismissal. The contract made the work property of the United States, with no restriction on later use, and the government as owner could decide where its own property stood.

What the court held

Ownership and contract controlled. A public-art commission that transfers ownership without a promise about duration or location leaves the artist with no constitutional claim when the owner removes the work. The case predates VARA, which was enacted in 1990, and it is the gap VARA was written to narrow.

What may have covered it

The loser was the artist, and no policy pays to keep a sold sculpture in place. The only cover was the contract itself: a bargained term on duration, location, and removal, which Serra did not have. For a working artist today, the lesson is to price the removal term into the commission, in writing, before the steel is ordered.

Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, the facts, and the state. Nothing here is a promise of coverage, and Artist Liability does not sell insurance on this page.

Sources

Second Circuit opinion, Justia

Back to all Case Files

Previous: Cohen v. G and M Realty: the 5Pointz whitewashNext: Carter v. Helmsley-Spear: work made for hire defeats VARA