Case File No. 03 · Sculpture and Installation
Carter v. Helmsley-Spear: work made for hire defeats VARA
Carter v. Helmsley-Spear, Inc., 71 F.3d 77 (2d Cir. 1995)
Annemoran777
Lobby sculpture, Key Tower
Photograph by Annemoran777, CC BY-SA 4.0. CC BY-SA 4.0 Source: Wikimedia Commons.
An illustrative lobby sculpture, not the Carter installation. No license-free image of the sculptors or their work exists.
- Court
- U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit, 1995
- Exposure
- Work made for hire, VARA scope, commission status
What happened
Three sculptors created a walk-through sculptural installation in the lobby of a Queens office building, under a commission agreement. When the building owner planned alterations, the artists sought a VARA injunction. The trial court applied a two-part recognized stature test, merit and recognition by experts or the art community, and found for the artists. The Second Circuit reversed. The work was a work made for hire, and VARA by its terms does not apply to work made for hire, so the injunction could not stand.
What the court held
VARA protects the author of a work of visual art, but not a work made for hire. How the commission is structured, employee or independent contractor, written agreement or not, can decide whether moral rights exist at all. The court never reached whether the lobby work had recognized stature.
What may have covered it
The losers were the artists, and the loss was status, not money. No liability policy fixes a work-for-hire finding. What may have helped was professional advice and a commission agreement that preserved independent contractor status and copyright, before the work was installed. Status is a contract decision, and it is made at signing, not at trial.
Coverage depends on the actual policy wording, the facts, and the state. Nothing here is a promise of coverage, and Artist Liability does not sell insurance on this page.